In any contract, a question arises: who bears the risk of non-performance?
Limiting and exempting liability clauses make it possible to respond to it. By these stipulations, one of the parties conventionally adjusts the extent of its contractual liability in the event of a breach of its obligations.
The validity in principle of such clauses has its roots in a fundamental principle of French civil law: contractual freedom (Art. 1102 of the Civil Code).
Thus, generally speaking, no legal provision prohibits the insertion of clauses limiting or exempting liability, including in adhesion contracts (Court of Cassation, 1st Civil Chamber, 19 January 1982, No. 80-15.745).
Limits to the principle of validity of clauses exempting or limiting liability
Breach of an essential contract obligation
Article 1170 of the Civil Code states that “any clause that deprives the essential obligation of the debtor of its substance is deemed to be unwritten”.
What does that mean? That one of the parties to the contract cannot rely on a clause limiting and exempting liability if this clause tends to exempt it from its main obligation.
Illustration by example.
In the early 1990s, a company sent a package containing a response to a public tender via Chronopost, a specialist in express transport.
The transport is delayed and when the package arrives the offer has expired, which automatically removes the company from the market.
The company sues Chronopost, which invokes a contractual stipulation according to which, in case of delay, its liability is limited to the cost of sending the letter, i.e. 122 francs in this case (30 euros in 2024).
The Court of Cassation considered the clause to be deemed unwritten: by guaranteeing delivery within a specific period of time, Chronopost had undertaken an essential obligation of speed and reliability; the clause, which contradicts its scope, is unenforceable (Court of Cassation, Commercial Chamber, 22 October 1996, No. 93-18.632).
Legal provisions for special contracts
Limiting and exempting liability clauses are prohibited or restricted in a number of special contracts (for example for certain types of deposit, transport or consumer contracts).
For example, in consumer law, “are irrebuttably presumed abusive and therefore prohibited, clauses whose object or effect is to eliminate or reduce the right to compensation for the damage suffered by the consumer in the event of a breach by the professional” (Court of Cassation, 1st Civil Chamber, 11 December 2019, No. 18-21.164).
Gross or fraudulent misconduct
Under article 1231-3 of the Civil Code, the parties’ contractual provisions and in particular the limitation of liability clause will fall if the non-performance is due to gross negligence (that which indicates an extremely serious negligence bordering on fraud) or fraudulent misconduct (intent to harm).
Exemption clauses from tortious liability
Since articles 1240 and 1241 of the Civil Code are matters of public policy, the clauses intended to exempt or mitigate the tortious liability of one of the parties are void (Court of Cassation, 1st Civil Chamber, 5 July 2017, No. 16-13.407).
Clauses limiting or exempting liability and third parties to the contract
The contract only creates obligations between the signatory parties. This is the relative effect of the contract (Art. 1199 of the Civil Code).
As a result, clauses limiting or exempting liability are generally declared unenforceable against third parties (Court of Cassation, 2nd Civil Chamber, 17 February 1955, No. 55-02.810; Court of Cassation, 2nd Civil Chamber, 15 June 1994, No. 92-18.048).
However, it should be noted that in a very particular situation involving a “form of contractual group” and a “para-contractual” liability, the Court of Cassation was able to rule that a third party could have a limitation of liability clause enforced against it (Court of Cassation, Commercial Chamber, 3 July 2024, No. 21-14.947, obs. D. Houtcieff, D. 2024, p. 1607).
This case law has yet to be confirmed and clarified.
In summary, limiting and exempting clauses are valid in principle, but strictly regulated: they cannot empty the contract of its substance, apply in the event of serious misconduct, or bypass special protections. Their effectiveness therefore depends as much on their drafting as on the context in which they are implemented.
Are you facing a dispute involving a limiting or exempting clause?
I support managers, shareholders and entrepreneurs in the management of their commercial conflicts.

